Benefit Ingredient: Lisbon Court of Appeal ruling of 12 September 2025

TRIBUNAL DA RELAÇÃO DE LISBONNE

Unofficial translation of the decision of the Tribunal da Relação de Lisboa of 12 September 2025 (case no. 13389/22.1T8LSB-A.L1-1), which authorises the lifting of banking secrecy on the accounts of Benefit Ingredient, Lda, in the judicial inquiry brought by its minority shareholder. Original text: https://jurisprudencia.pt/acordao/237857/

Case details

Court: Tribunal da Relação de Lisboa (Lisbon Court of Appeal)
Date: 12 September 2025
Reference: case no. 13389/22.1T8LSB-A.L1-1
Rapporteur: Susana Santos Silva
Nature: application to lift banking secrecy
Decision: application granted (single-judge decision)

Lifting of banking secrecy – Right to information – Commercial company

Summary

Banking secrecy must give way to the duty to cooperate in establishing the material truth where lifting it is necessary for the proper administration of justice. This is the case where the information sought on bank transactions carried out by the second defendant through accounts belonging to the first defendant is essential to protect the rights of the claimant. As a shareholder, the claimant has a direct and legitimate interest in obtaining truthful, complete and clarifying information on the management of the company. This information affects its position as a shareholder, the exercise of its voting rights and its ability to defend its interests within the company. Since previous legal steps failed to obtain it, the lifting of secrecy is justified.

Full text – translation

I. Report

NORME FRANCE, SARL, on the basis of Article 216 of the Commercial Companies Code (CSC) and Articles 1048 et seq. of the Code of Civil Procedure (CPC), brought special judicial inquiry proceedings against BENEFIT INGREDIENT, LDA. and against its managing director, referred to as “A”, in order to obtain information on the life of the company that had been refused to it.

The claimant sought, in particular, explanations and supporting documents concerning: the date and terms of repayment of Mr A’s personal debt to Benefit Ingredient; the existence of contracts governing the successive transfers of funds; the legal and tax basis of the loans granted by the company to Mr A; the recurring cash-flow difficulties and late payments to suppliers; the late filing or non-filing of the annual reports and accounts of the company and its subsidiaries; the fate of a bank deposit of 647,000 euros, allegedly allocated to the Portugal 2020 programme, the funds of which were allegedly transferred in 2020 to Mr A; the proceeds of the sale of shareholdings in Aroeira Aldeia and other entities; the nature and justification of transfers made in 2020 to We Love Success, to individuals and to other companies; the agreements relating to the project to represent the Gifi brand in Portugal, which, according to the claimant, was financed by Benefit Ingredient; the possible use of Benefit Ingredient’s assets, employees and resources for other projects or personal interests; documented information on legal proceedings brought by Colossal Ltd; the changes in shareholding in Aroeira Aldeia; and finally, the status of tax, social security, supplier and intra-group debts, as well as any regularisation of personal expenses paid by the company.

The claimant stated that it held two shares representing 30% of the share capital. Mr A held 70% of the capital and had been managing director since the company’s incorporation on 3 May 2018. According to the claimant, the managing director repeatedly failed to provide truthful, complete and clarifying information on the management, despite requests made by letter, by email and in person. It accused him of running the company as if he were its sole shareholder and of using its resources for his own benefit.

In particular, it reported advances or loans of 848,811.31 euros granted to Mr A, including a transfer of 675,980.06 euros directly from the company’s account to his personal account, with no written document and no known legal, accounting or tax justification. It also reported persistent cash-flow difficulties, the transfer to Mr A of funds corresponding to a deposit of 647,000 euros, and payments of personal expenses by the company: school fees for a family member, trips abroad and other expenses. Transfers from the company’s accounts to Mr A’s personal account were allegedly made, in particular, in 2019 and 2020 without any justification being provided.

In its request for evidence concerning documents held by third parties, the claimant had sought the December 2020 bank statements from BPI, as well as the statements for July, August, November and December 2019 and January to June 2020 from BPI, Santander, Novo Banco and BCP.

The defendants and their managing director, duly summoned, did not file a defence. By judgment of 28 February 2023, the court granted the claim and ordered the defendants to provide the information requested in the application, together with supporting documents, within thirty days. As the judgment became final and the information was not provided voluntarily, the court ordered a judicial inquiry into the company on 5 February 2024 and appointed an expert. The expert was required, in particular, to examine the company’s assets, books and documents, including those held by third parties, to gather written information and to ask the judge to hear any persons refusing to provide the required information.

On 15 October 2024, the expert stated that he was unable to verify the nature of the fund movements on the basis of the accounting and tax information available to him. On 31 October 2024, the claimant therefore requested that the banks be served directly so that they would provide the necessary statements. The court so ordered on 12 November 2024.

The banks refused to provide the documents, citing banking secrecy under Articles 78 and 79 of the General Regime for Credit Institutions and Financial Companies. Santander, Millennium BCP, BPI and Novo Banco requested either authorisation from the account holder or an indication of the legal provision allowing secrecy to be waived.

On 19 March 2025, the claimant filed the present application to lift banking secrecy. It pointed out that the disputed movements included, in particular, 647,000 euros transferred to the managing director, payments of personal expenses totalling 15,955.67 euros and transfers to his personal account totalling 44,218.28 euros between 2019 and 2020. It argued that the annual accounts for 2021 to 2024 had not been submitted and that, despite the final judgment and repeated requests, neither the company nor its managing director had provided the documents. The documents provided consisted mainly of Excel spreadsheets that were insufficient to verify the accounts. The bank statements were therefore essential for the effective enforcement of the judgment and the protection of its rights.

On 19 June 2025, the court of first instance, finding that the application had been filed in time and that the banks’ refusal was legitimate, referred the question provided for in Article 135(3) of the Code of Criminal Procedure to the appeal court.

II. Questions to be decided

The court must examine whether banking secrecy applies and, if so, whether it should be lifted in light of the duty to cooperate with the courts.

III. Reasoning

A. Facts

The facts to be taken into account are those set out in the report.

B. Law

Article 417(1) of the CPC, on the duty to cooperate in establishing the truth, provides that every person, whether or not a party to the proceedings, must cooperate, answer questions, submit to the necessary inspections, provide the information requested and carry out the acts ordered. Under paragraph 2, an unjustified refusal may result in a fine and, where the refusal comes from a party, may be assessed by the court as a matter of evidence. Paragraph 3, however, allows a legitimate refusal, in particular where it would breach professional secrecy. Paragraph 4 then refers, with the necessary adaptations, to the rules of criminal procedure on the legitimacy of the refusal and on release from secrecy.

The duty to cooperate applies to parties and third parties alike. It aims directly at helping to establish the truth and, more broadly, at enabling the administration of justice. It guarantees the right of access to the courts and the right to a fair trial, protected by Article 20(1) and (4) of the Portuguese Constitution, as well as the rights of action, defence and evidence.

The right to evidence is not, however, absolute. It may conflict with other equally protected rights or interests, in particular privacy and legally recognised secrets. The court must weigh up the interests at stake. It may not, however, deprive a person of any possibility of using a means of evidence where such a restriction would make it practically impossible to prove the facts on which their right is based.

The banks Santander Totta, Millennium BCP, Banco BPI and Novo Banco were asked to produce the statements of the accounts held by the defendant company for the periods indicated. They refused on the ground that this information was covered by Articles 78 and 79 of Decree-Law No. 298/92 of 31 December. Article 78 makes subject to secrecy, in particular, the names of clients, deposit accounts, their movements and other banking transactions. Article 79 provides for exceptions, in particular with the client’s authorisation, and in certain cases listed by law.

The information requested is indeed covered by banking secrecy; the banks’ initial refusal was therefore legitimate. Banking secrecy protects both the public interest in the proper functioning of banking, which is based on trust, and the private interests of clients, in particular the confidentiality of their private lives. It is not, however, absolute. Because of its connection with the sphere of property, it may have to give way to other constitutionally protected rights or interests where their protection requires access to the information concerned.

It must therefore be determined, in accordance with the principle of the prevailing higher interest referred to in Article 135(3) of the Code of Criminal Procedure, applicable by virtue of the reference in Article 417(4) of the CPC, whether the public interest in the proper administration of justice outweighs, in this case, the interest in maintaining banking secrecy.

In the present case, the claimant has put forward evidence of significant transfers from the company’s accounts to the managing director, in particular the movement of 647,000 euros, payments of personal expenses and transfers to his personal account. The information and documents had already been ordered by a final judgment but had not been provided. Neither the judicial inquiry nor the intervention of an expert made it possible to obtain the necessary supporting documents. The bank statements are therefore the indispensable means of verifying the movements, understanding the company’s accounts and financial results, and giving practical effect to the judgment delivered.

Shareholders’ right to information, enshrined in general terms in Article 21(1)(c) of the CSC, is an essential instrument for exercising other shareholder rights, in particular the right to vote, for monitoring the company’s activity and for protecting shareholders’ investment, especially that of minority shareholders. For private limited companies, Article 214 of the CSC guarantees every shareholder who so requests the right to obtain from the managers truthful, complete and clarifying information on the management of the company.

Judicial inquiry is the special procedural route for obtaining such information where its disclosure is expressly or implicitly refused, or where it is presumed to be false, incomplete or insufficiently clear. In the present case, the court had already ruled that there were grounds for such an inquiry. Despite this, no supporting accounting evidence, in particular the bank statements for the period concerned, could be obtained.

Access to the requested bank statements must therefore be considered essential to ensure enforcement of the judgment and to respect the claimant’s rights, which have already been recognised by the courts. The information sought is essential to protect its rights as a shareholder and cannot be obtained by any other means, as shown by the successive refusals in the proceedings. The public interest in the proper administration and delivery of justice must therefore prevail.

The conditions for authorising the lifting of banking secrecy are met for the following documents: (i) the statement, from Banco BPI, of the account held by the defendant company for December 2020; (ii) the statements of the accounts held by that company with BPI, Santander Totta, Novo Banco and Millennium BCP for July, August, November and December 2019, and January, February, March, April, May and June 2020. Banking secrecy must give way to the duty to cooperate in establishing the material truth.

IV. Operative part

On these grounds, the Court decides to grant the application to lift professional secrecy and authorises, with banking secrecy lifted, the production in the proceedings by the banks Santander Totta, Millennium BCP, Banco BPI and Novo Banco of the following documents :

  1. The bank statement of the account held by the defendant company with Banco BPI – Banco Português de Investimento, S.A., for December 2020.
  2. The bank statements of the accounts held by the defendant company with Banco BPI, Santander Totta, Novo Banco and Banco Millennium BCP, for July, August, November and December 2019, and for January, February, March, April, May and June 2020.

Costs are awarded against the defendants, who have lost the action, in accordance with Article 527 of the CPC.

Lisbon, 12 September 2025
Susana Santos Silva