Adventure in China : Paul Bakery China

Harold Victor Levillair claims :

His position as Chief Executive of Paul Bakery Group China !

Paul Bakery China Levillair Group

It is, however, important to highlight the distinction between the Holder Group, which owns the PAUL'S brand, and the Levillair Group, which was responsible for its development in China.

Now that the scene is set, let us look at the reality from an angle closer to the truth.

The Paul Bakery China venture does indeed appear to involve some interesting details, which have been brought before the courts from various angles.

On this subject, here is an article published in the July/August 2010 issue of Feature Retail, which we have translated.

Article Chinois sur Paul Bakery China et Harold Victor Levillair

La traduction :

PAUL’S: A Brand Mired in Debt

By Monica Liau – FEATURE Retail, July/August 2010

Page 24 :


The group and its presence in China

Founded in 1889, the Holder Group owns seven well-known brands in France. The best known is PAUL, which has 750 outlets in France and around a hundred more elsewhere in the world, notably in Korea, Taiwan and the Middle East. The brand also enjoys a certain reputation in China. So why has its Chinese subsidiary run into so many difficulties ?

 

As the holder of the PAUL’S Bakery franchise rights in China, the Levillair Group has faced extensive criticism: disorganized financial management, unpaid debts and management problems.

The creditors reportedly include the logistics company Clasquin, the food importer Sinodis, several specialized investors, construction and interior design companies, employees, and the Holder Group itself.

Francis Mouly, former operations director of PAUL’S Bakery, estimates that the debts accumulated by Harold Victor Levillair amount to at least 12 million euros.

According to reports, the Holder Group attempted as early as 2009 to regain control of PAUL’S Bakery in China, but the debts of the Shanghai outlets reportedly made this difficult.

A loss-making operation

The Levillair Group’s debts raise many questions.

According to well-informed sources, Levillair Group owed Clasquin approximately one million yuan in fees related to the import of goods intended for PAUL’S.

A former PAUL’S employee explains :

“Clasquin had imported raw materials from France. But when the goods arrived, we didn’t pay for them, and that’s when the problems started. Each delivery was practically a full container, worth around 300,000 yuans.”

When the global financial crisis began to bite in 2009, Clasquin reportedly withdrew the payment terms it had granted its client and requested the seizure of the last shipment.
This shipment included, among other things, products used to make bread and pastries.
The goods reportedly remained in warehouses for several months. As the customs duties had not been paid, the products eventually deteriorated and had to be destroyed.

Clasquin et le groupe Holder entretenaient pourtant de bonnes relations. Une compensation aurait éventuellement pu être trouvée, mais les dettes n'auraient pas été intégralement remboursées.
En raison du caractère encore non résolu de cette affaire, Clasquin aurait refusé de faire davantage de commentaires.

Clasquin and the Holder Group nevertheless enjoyed a good relationship. A settlement may eventually have been reached, but the debts were reportedly never repaid in full.
Because the matter remains unresolved, Clasquin reportedly declined to comment further.
PAUL’S outlets and workshops also gradually began to close.
A former employee says the closures notably affected outlets whose operating permits were problematic.
The PAUL’S outlet in the Portman hotel reportedly ceased trading in May 2010.

The article also mentions outlets whose operating licenses were held in the name of the property owners rather than the operating company. Some outlets allegedly even operated without proper authorization.

Investor losses

The situation also reportedly caused significant losses for small investors and partners in the group.

Francis Mouly, one of Levillair’s first partners in China, says he invested 50,000 euros in February 2009.
In return, he was to receive shares representing 30% of the company’s capital. He claims, however, that he never received the promised shares.
He adds that other investors allegedly suffered even greater losses.

Some of them were investors from Qatar and Dubai, among other places. They had reportedly initially agreed to invest six million dollars in exchange for 35% of the capital.
According to the article, these investors never recovered their money.
The four investors reportedly confirmed their involvement in the Chinese project but declined to comment further on the matter.

A dispute with the group’s former lawyer

The Levillair Group is also reportedly facing legal action brought by a person who had previously acted as its legal counsel

This lawyer, whose name is not disclosed, reportedly represented the group’s interests when it set up in Shanghai a few years earlier.
He then allegedly brought proceedings against Harold Victor Levillair for non-payment of his fees.
He also reportedly filed a complaint with the bar association.
The article states that the situation led to difficulties regarding the group’s legal representation.

Summary – Holder Group, PAUL’S and Harold Levillair

Item Reported information
Holder Group Founded in 1889; owns several brands, including PAUL'S Bakery.
PAUL'S in France Around 750 outlets, according to the FEATURE Retail article of July/August 2010.
PAUL'S abroad Around 100 outlets, according to the same article.
Levillair in China Set up in Shanghai in 2007; the article mentions seven PAUL'S outlets.
Levillair's debts At least 12 million euros, an estimate attributed to Francis Mouly in the article.
Francis Mouly's investment 50,000 euros, according to his statements reported in the article.
Arab investors The article mentions an announced investment of 6 million dollars in exchange for 35% of the capital.
Pavilion Costes Announced investment of 4 to 5 million euros in 2009, according to the article.
Harold Levillair – professional profile A profile text describes him as general manager of Pavillon by Costes Paris in Shanghai and credits him with a role in developing the brand in China. It mentions more than 20 years of international experience and highlights his blending of French refinement with Shanghai's modern sophistication.
Claimed positioning and leadership The professional profile emphasizes his role as a bridge between cultures, as well as his vision, sense of innovation and operational skills in developing the Costes name in Asia.

About Pavillon Costes… still in China

Here is what Harold Victor Levillair claims, and what actually happened.
Read more here